When Warren Evans, captain of the football team and your average goody-two-shoes, finds out he's been assigned another student to tutor, he doesn't think much of it. He's been a peer tutor for years! However, after a not-so-pleasant meeting with the student in question, he's not quite sure it'll all play out the way he wants it to. Turns out Robert Mills, the quiet yet pretentious classmate he must work with week to week, isn't exactly keen on the idea of tutoring himself.